What Does Your Brokerage Cost You Per Closing? Do the Math

Producing real estate agent calculating the effective brokerage cost for each closing

Executive Summary

You know your commission split, but do you know what your brokerage actually costs you every time you close? For producing agents, converting annual brokerage expenses into a cost-per-closing number makes it much easier to compare models, measure value and understand what happens to profitability as production grows.

Liked this post? Share with others!

What Does Your Brokerage Cost You Per Closing? Do the Math

Most real estate agents know their commission split. Far fewer know exactly what their brokerage costs them per closing.

For a producing agent, that number can be far more useful than the percentage printed in a compensation plan.

Your brokerage may take a percentage of commission. It may charge transaction fees. There may be recurring fees or other required costs depending on the model. Looking at those expenses separately can make them seem relatively small.

Put them together and divide them by the number of transactions you actually close, and suddenly you have a much clearer number:

Your effective brokerage cost per closing.

Once you know that number, it becomes much easier to decide whether your current brokerage economics still make sense for the business you have built.

Start With What You Actually Paid

Don’t begin with the brokerage’s advertised commission split.

Begin with your own numbers.

Look at a completed year or another meaningful period and calculate the total amount your business paid under your brokerage compensation arrangement.

Depending on your particular brokerage, that may include amounts retained from commission splits, transaction charges, recurring brokerage fees or other required costs.

Then count the transactions you closed during the same period.

The basic calculation is simple:

Total brokerage cost ÷ number of closings = average brokerage cost per closing.

For example, suppose an agent paid $25,000 in total brokerage costs across 25 closings.

That works out to an average of $1,000 per closing.

If another agent paid $40,000 across 25 closings, the average is $1,600 per closing.

Now you have something concrete to evaluate.

Why Cost Per Closing Is So Useful

Commission percentages can be surprisingly abstract.

An 80/20 split tells you how commissions are divided, but it doesn’t immediately tell you how much your brokerage relationship costs your business over an entire year.

Cost per closing turns that expense into a unit you already understand.

You know what a closing represents.

You know what you did to acquire the client.

You know what you spent marketing the property or generating the opportunity.

You know how much time went into managing the transaction.

Add the effective brokerage cost and you get a more complete picture of the economics of producing that closing.

Run the Numbers on Your Last Year

Consider a hypothetical producing agent with $200,000 in gross commission income on an 80/20 split.

If the full amount were subject to that split and there were no cap or other adjustment, the brokerage portion would be $40,000.

If the agent completed 25 transactions, that’s an average of $1,600 per closing before considering any additional required brokerage costs.

Now imagine the agent completes 35 transactions the following year and generates $280,000 in gross commission income under the same assumptions.

The 20% brokerage portion would be $56,000.

See also  The Real Estate Agent Revenue Trap: More Production, More Brokerage Fees

The agent became more productive.

The brokerage also received considerably more money.

This is precisely why producing agents should examine more than the headline split.

Don’t Ignore Your Average Commission

Transaction count alone doesn’t determine brokerage cost under a percentage-based model.

The size of the commission matters too.

An agent moving into higher-priced properties can generate substantially more commission income without dramatically increasing transaction volume.

That can make the brokerage’s share increase even when the number of closings remains relatively stable.

Suppose two transactions require a similar amount of brokerage interaction, but one generates twice the commission of the other.

Under an uncapped percentage split, the brokerage may receive twice as much from the higher-commission transaction.

That does not automatically make the arrangement unreasonable.

It does make it worth understanding.

Then Separate the Cost of Leads From the Cost of the Brokerage

One of the most important distinctions for producing agents is where the business came from.

A brokerage-generated opportunity might reasonably be evaluated differently from a client generated entirely by the agent.

If your transactions come primarily from your own database, referrals, prospecting, advertising, website, content or professional relationships, you are already funding or performing the work required to create the opportunity.

That changes the economic calculation.

If you are generating most of your own business, read our guide to choosing a brokerage when you generate your own leads.

Producing agents should know which expenses are helping create business and which expenses exist because of the brokerage compensation model.

Do the Calculation by Business Source

You can take the analysis further.

Separate your closings by lead source.

How many came from past clients?

How many came from referrals?

How many came from your own marketing?

How many came through opportunities supplied by the brokerage, if any?

This gives you a much clearer picture of who is creating the economic engine behind your business.

If nearly every transaction originates from an asset you created, such as your database, reputation, marketing or referral network, brokerage economics deserve particularly close attention.

What Did the Brokerage Actually Provide for Each Closing?

Now examine the other side of the equation.

What are you receiving?

Brokerage supervision and appropriate broker support have value.

So can technology, training, administrative resources, marketing resources, office infrastructure and lead generation when an agent actually uses them.

The mistake is assuming that everything included in a brokerage package creates equal value for every agent.

An experienced producer with an established technology stack, marketing operation, lead sources and business systems may use relatively few bundled services.

Another agent may rely heavily on them.

The correct question isn’t:

“How much does my brokerage provide?”

It is:

“Which brokerage resources materially help my business, and what would it cost me to replace the ones I actually use?”

See also  Can You Be Successful Without NAR? Let's Get Real

Producing Agents Should Look at Marginal Brokerage Cost Too

Average cost per closing tells you what has already happened.

Marginal cost tells you what happens next.

Ask what your brokerage will receive from your next transaction.

Then ask what happens if you close five additional transactions this year.

Or ten.

This is especially important under an uncapped commission split because additional production can continue increasing the brokerage’s compensation.

That’s the issue we examined when asking why commission splits can become more painful as agents become more productive.

Growth should improve the economics of your business.

Understanding the marginal brokerage cost tells you how much of that growth you actually keep.

A Cap Can Completely Change the Calculation

If your brokerage uses a commission cap, include that in the analysis.

A producing agent who reaches the cap may experience very different economics after reaching it.

That is why comparing brokerage models solely by their advertised split can be misleading.

A capped split and an uncapped split are not economically identical.

Neither should automatically be compared with a transaction-based or 100% commission brokerage using only the percentage shown in advertising.

Calculate the projected total annual cost under each model at your actual production level.

Then calculate the cost per closing.

That creates a much more useful comparison.

Now Model Your Next Production Level

After calculating last year’s numbers, run the calculation again using the production you want to achieve next.

If you closed 20 transactions last year and want to close 30, what happens to your total brokerage expense?

If your gross commission income was $150,000 and you are targeting $225,000, what happens?

If your average commission increases, what happens?

Don’t assume the cost scales efficiently.

Calculate it.

The goal is to determine whether more production creates better economics for your business or simply creates proportionally more revenue for the brokerage.

Your Brokerage Should Be One Line in a Bigger Profitability Calculation

Brokerage cost should not be evaluated in isolation.

A real estate agent is running a business.

You may spend money on lead generation, photography, marketing, CRM technology, websites, administrative help, transportation, professional services and other operating expenses.

Every dollar has a purpose.

If you spend money on advertising, you want the advertising to produce opportunities.

If you hire administrative help, you want time and capacity in return.

If you purchase technology, you want the technology to improve some part of the business.

Apply the same standard to the brokerage.

What does the money produce for you?

Beware of Comparing One Brokerage Fee With Another Brokerage’s Entire Model

Agents can also make bad comparisons in the opposite direction.

For example, comparing only a transaction fee at one brokerage with the commission split at another may leave out other required costs or meaningful differences in what is provided.

See also  Where to Hang Your Florida Real Estate License Without Monthly or Annual Brokerage Fees

The right comparison is comprehensive.

For each brokerage you are considering, identify the compensation structure and the applicable required costs.

Estimate those costs at your own production level.

Then examine the services and brokerage environment attached to them.

Only then can you make a useful comparison.

At Higher Production, Small Differences Become Real Money

For a low-volume business, a difference of a few hundred dollars per closing may not appear transformational.

Multiply it across 20, 30, 40 or more transactions and the annual effect changes quickly.

A $500 difference across 30 closings is $15,000.

An $800 difference across 30 closings is $24,000.

A $1,000 difference across 30 closings is $30,000.

That is capital an agent could potentially retain as income or reinvest into the business.

Again, a more expensive brokerage may provide value that justifies the difference.

But the agent should know the number.

What Could You Do With the Difference?

This is where brokerage economics stop being an accounting exercise.

Suppose a different business model allowed you to retain an additional $15,000 annually while still providing the brokerage relationship and support you need.

What could that money do inside your business?

It could fund marketing.

It could help pay for administrative support.

It could fund better photography or content.

It could support a geographic farming campaign.

It could build reserves for slower periods.

Or you could simply keep more of the income your business generated.

The answer will be different for every agent.

The important thing is recognizing that brokerage cost has an opportunity cost too.

The Best Brokerage for Producing Agents Has to Work on Paper

If you’re looking for the best brokerage for producing real estate agents, ignore the recruiting pitch for a moment and open a calculator.

Use your own production.

Use your own average commissions.

Use your own transaction count.

Use the costs applicable to the brokerage model you’re considering.

Then examine the resulting annual expense and cost per closing.

After that, evaluate what you receive for the money.

An established agent can make a far better brokerage decision from those numbers than from a commission percentage alone.

Know the Number Before Your Next Closing

You already know what your last closing sold for.

You probably know the commission.

You almost certainly know how much work went into getting the client and reaching the closing table.

Now know what the brokerage cost you too.

Calculate last year’s total.

Divide it by your closings.

Then calculate what happens at your next production target.

You may discover that your current brokerage offers excellent value for the money.

Or you may find that your effective cost per closing is much larger than you thought.

Either way, a producing agent should know the number.

Get Exclusive Content & Insights

Join our community for the latest real estate industry trends, expert tips, and special offers delivered straight to your inbox.

Easy Realty Icon
Get Exclusive Content & Insights
Join our community for the latest real estate industry trends, expert tips, and special offers delivered straight to your inbox.
Easy Realty Icon

Request A Call

Fill out the form below, and we will be in touch shortly. 

Learn how we helped 100 top brands gain success