Why High-Producing Real Estate Agents Should Recalculate Their Brokerage Every Year

High-producing real estate professional conducting an annual review of brokerage costs and business needs

Executive Summary

Your production, lead sources, systems and experience can change dramatically in a year. Your brokerage economics may need to change too. High-producing agents should periodically calculate what they actually pay, which services they use, where their business comes from and whether the current brokerage still makes sense at the next production level.

Liked this post? Share with others!

Why High-Producing Real Estate Agents Should Recalculate Their Brokerage Every Year

Your real estate business probably does not look exactly the same as it did a year ago. Production changes. Lead sources change. Expenses change. Your database grows. Your experience increases. The amount of support you need from a brokerage can change too.

But many producing agents leave one of their largest business relationships completely untouched: their brokerage.

If you are a high-producing real estate agent, your brokerage should not be a decision you made once and then stopped evaluating.

At least once a year, pull the numbers and ask a straightforward question:

Does this brokerage still make financial and operational sense for the business I have today?

Your Brokerage Decision Has an Expiration Date

Not because you necessarily need to leave.

Because your business keeps changing.

The brokerage you chose when you were closing six transactions a year may have been exactly what you needed at the time.

If you are now closing 20, 30 or 40 transactions, generating your own business and operating with established systems, the decision deserves to be made again using today’s numbers.

The answer may still be the same brokerage.

But it should be an active decision rather than inertia.

Start With What You Actually Paid Your Brokerage

Begin the annual review with dollars, not percentages.

Look at what your brokerage relationship actually cost during the previous year.

Depending on your compensation agreement, that could include commission retained by the brokerage, transaction charges, recurring fees and other required brokerage costs.

Add the applicable amounts together.

Now you have your annual brokerage cost.

If the number surprises you, that’s useful information.

A producing agent can spend a substantial amount through a brokerage arrangement without ever receiving a single large invoice because the money may be removed incrementally as transactions close.

Compare Brokerage Cost With Gross Commission Income

Next, compare your brokerage expense with your gross commission income.

Suppose you generated $200,000 in gross commission income and your total brokerage cost was $30,000.

The useful number isn’t simply $30,000.

You now know that the brokerage relationship represented 15% of gross commission income in this simplified example.

Now compare that with the preceding period.

Did the percentage increase or decrease?

More importantly, did the actual dollar expense increase?

If the brokerage received considerably more money because your production increased, determine whether the value you received also increased.

Calculate Your Brokerage Cost Per Closing

Producing agents should also know their effective brokerage cost on a transaction basis.

Take the total brokerage cost and divide it by your total closings for the same period.

If you paid $30,000 across 30 closings, the average brokerage cost was $1,000 per closing.

If you paid $45,000 across the same 30 closings, the average was $1,500.

We cover this calculation more deeply in our guide to calculating your real estate brokerage cost per closing.

Knowing the number gives you a common unit for evaluating alternative brokerage structures.

Then Ask Where Your Business Actually Came From

This is where an annual brokerage review becomes much more revealing.

Look at every closing and identify its source.

See also  The Brokerage Comparison Most Agents Never Make: What Are You Actually Getting for the Money?

How many clients came from the brokerage?

How many came from your database?

How many were repeat clients?

How many came from referrals?

How many resulted from marketing you paid for?

How many came from prospecting, content, community relationships, a website or your personal reputation?

There is an enormous difference between a brokerage that materially contributes to your pipeline and a brokerage relationship where the agent produces nearly every opportunity independently.

If you have become an agent who generates your own real estate leads, that should be factored into your annual review.

Count the Brokerage Services You Actually Used

Next, stop evaluating brokerage services by whether they are technically available.

Ask whether you used them.

If your brokerage includes training, did you use it?

If technology is included, is it technology your business actually relies on?

If marketing services are available, did they contribute to your production?

If office infrastructure is part of the model, did you use it?

If leads are promoted as a brokerage benefit, how many closings resulted from them?

A long list of available benefits can sound impressive during recruiting.

But a producing agent should evaluate benefits according to actual usage and actual business value.

Do Not Undervalue Brokerage Support

There is an important distinction here.

Experienced agents may become increasingly self-sufficient, but that does not make brokerage support irrelevant.

An experienced agent can still encounter an unusual contract issue, compliance question or difficult transaction that requires meaningful broker involvement.

That support has value.

The question is whether the structure surrounding it makes sense for the amount and type of support you actually need.

We examined this more closely when asking how much brokerage support an experienced real estate agent actually needs.

Review How Much More Independent You Became

Production is only one measure of how your business changed during the year.

Independence matters too.

Perhaps you built a stronger database.

Maybe your referral business increased.

You may have developed better technology systems.

Your personal brand may be generating more direct inquiries.

You may have added administrative help.

You may simply be much better at handling the normal problems that once required assistance.

Every one of those developments changes your relationship with the brokerage.

An agent can grow into a very different business while remaining on exactly the same brokerage arrangement.

Review Your Commission Split in Dollars

If you are on a traditional commission split, calculate what the percentage represented in dollars for the year.

Then calculate what it would represent if you hit next year’s production target.

This is especially important for an uncapped split.

A percentage that seems reasonable in isolation can become a substantial expense as gross commission income rises.

If you haven’t already done the calculation, read when a traditional real estate commission split may stop making sense.

The objective is not to prove that commission splits are bad.

It is to determine whether your particular split still represents good value for your particular business.

Look at What Happens If You Have a Better Year Next Year

Don’t perform an annual brokerage review entirely through the rearview mirror.

See also  REO Real Estate Training for Agents: How to Build a Bank-Owned Property Specialty

Model the next year too.

If you increase gross commission income by 25%, what happens to brokerage cost?

If you close ten additional transactions, what happens?

If your average commission increases, what happens?

If more business comes from repeat and referral clients, does the brokerage compensation structure change at all?

Your brokerage model should be evaluated against where your business is going, not simply where it has been.

Review Your Brokerage Before You Need to

Many agents think seriously about their brokerage only after something goes wrong.

They become frustrated with a policy.

A transaction produces a problem.

A fee changes.

A commission statement catches their attention.

Or another brokerage begins recruiting them.

That is not the ideal time to begin understanding one of the most important relationships in your business.

Perform the review while everything is fine.

You make better business decisions when there isn’t a crisis forcing the decision.

Calculate the Opportunity Cost of Staying

Your current brokerage doesn’t have to be bad for another model to make more economic sense.

That distinction matters.

Suppose your current brokerage costs $35,000 annually.

Suppose an alternative structure that meets your actual operating needs would cost $15,000 under the same production assumptions.

The relevant difference is $20,000.

Now ask what $20,000 could do inside your business.

It could fund lead generation.

It could help pay for an assistant or transaction support.

It could fund better marketing, content or photography.

It could build additional cash reserves.

It could be invested elsewhere.

Or it could simply remain with you as additional income.

The purpose of the comparison isn’t to assume the cheaper model is better.

It is to force the more important question:

Does the additional $20,000 spent with the current brokerage return at least $20,000 of meaningful value to the business?

Do Not Ignore the Cost of Switching

An honest annual brokerage review also needs to consider friction.

Changing brokerages is not simply a mathematical exercise.

An established agent may have marketing materials, technology, processes, online profiles and business systems connected to the current brokerage.

There may be administrative work involved in changing affiliation.

The agent should therefore evaluate the complete business impact rather than switching over a trivial difference.

But transition friction should not become an excuse for indefinitely remaining in an arrangement that no longer makes financial sense.

Review Whether Your Brokerage Still Fits Your Brand

The financial review is only part of the annual checkup.

Your marketing may have changed too.

Producing agents frequently become more intentional about their personal brand as their businesses mature.

Your name, reputation, website, database, referral relationships and marketing may become increasingly important sources of future business.

If personal brand control matters more to you now than it did when you joined the brokerage, include that in the review.

We’ve addressed that issue in our guide to choosing a brokerage when you want to build your own real estate brand.

See also  The Hidden Costs of Staying Put Too Long

Compare Real Alternatives, Not Recruiting Slogans

Once you understand your current economics, you can make useful comparisons.

Compare your present structure with actual alternatives.

That might include another traditional commission split, a capped model, a transaction-based brokerage or a 100% commission brokerage.

But run each alternative using your own production.

Include the applicable fees.

Evaluate the services you would actually use.

Compare access to brokerage support.

Consider operational flexibility and how the model fits your established business.

The best-looking percentage is not necessarily the best brokerage.

The Best Brokerage for High-Producing Agents Can Change

An agent searching for the best brokerage for high-producing real estate agents should recognize that “best” is not necessarily a permanent designation.

Your needs at 10 annual closings may differ from your needs at 30.

Your needs when the brokerage generates much of your business may differ from your needs after referrals and personal marketing generate most of it.

Your needs before building a personal brand may differ from your needs after clients routinely seek you out by name.

A brokerage has to fit the business you operate now.

100% Commission May Become More Relevant as Production Increases

As agents become more productive, 100% commission brokerage models often deserve closer examination because the economics are structurally different from a traditional uncapped percentage split.

That does not mean every 100% commission brokerage will be right for every producing agent.

Agents still need to understand applicable transaction charges, other brokerage costs, support and operational fit.

But the comparison can become increasingly significant as gross commission income rises.

The more you produce, the larger the dollar impact of a percentage-based split can become.

A Simple Annual Brokerage Review

You don’t need a complicated spreadsheet to start.

Once a year, answer these questions:

  • How much did I pay my brokerage in total?
  • What was my brokerage cost per closing?
  • How much of my business did I generate myself?
  • Which brokerage services did I actually use?
  • How much brokerage support did I actually need?
  • What did my commission split represent in dollars?
  • What would my current model cost at next year’s production target?
  • What would realistic alternatives cost at the same production?
  • Does my current brokerage still fit how I operate and market my business?

Then make a decision.

Staying can be a decision.

Changing can be a decision.

Doing nothing because you never looked at the numbers is not much of a decision at all.

Your Brokerage Should Have to Earn the Relationship Again

You work every year to earn your clients’ business.

Your vendors have to continue providing value.

Your marketing has to continue producing results.

Your technology has to continue being useful.

Your brokerage relationship deserves the same standard.

That doesn’t mean constantly shopping for a new brokerage.

It means knowing what you pay, understanding what you receive and making sure the relationship still makes sense for the business you are building.

High-producing agents change.

Their businesses change.

Their economics change.

Once a year, make your brokerage earn its place in the business again.

Get Exclusive Content & Insights

Join our community for the latest real estate industry trends, expert tips, and special offers delivered straight to your inbox.

Easy Realty Icon
Get Exclusive Content & Insights
Join our community for the latest real estate industry trends, expert tips, and special offers delivered straight to your inbox.
Easy Realty Icon

Request A Call

Fill out the form below, and we will be in touch shortly. 

Learn how we helped 100 top brands gain success