Your Brokerage Should Get Cheaper as You Become More Successful

High-producing Florida real estate professional evaluating a brokerage built to scale with business success

Executive Summary

As you become more successful, your database grows, your referral business strengthens and your need for day-to-day brokerage involvement may decline. So why should your brokerage keep getting more expensive? High-producing agents should understand whether their brokerage economics improve as the business becomes more productive and self-sufficient.

Liked this post? Share with others!

Your Brokerage Should Get Cheaper as You Become More Successful

Success is supposed to improve the economics of your real estate business.

You become more experienced. You build a database. Past clients begin sending referrals. Your marketing gets better. Your personal brand becomes more valuable. You develop systems that allow you to handle more transactions with less friction.

So why, for many producing agents, does the brokerage become more expensive at exactly the same time?

For a high-producing real estate agent, that question deserves more than a glance at a commission split.

As you become more successful, your business should create leverage. And ideally, your brokerage should become cheaper relative to the value of the business you produce, not more expensive simply because you produce more.

Early in Your Career, You May Need More From a Brokerage

A newer agent can have legitimate reasons to choose a brokerage that provides a substantial package of resources.

There is an enormous amount to learn.

Contracts are unfamiliar. Transactions are unfamiliar. Lead generation may be unfamiliar. The agent may still be developing basic business systems, learning brokerage procedures and figuring out how to work effectively with buyers and sellers.

At that stage, an agent may reasonably value extensive training, technology, marketing resources, leads, office infrastructure or additional assistance.

But an agent’s needs do not remain frozen forever.

Successful Agents Usually Become More Self-Sufficient

Experience compounds.

After years in the business, a producing agent may already have established lead sources, a database, a CRM, marketing systems, transaction processes, a professional network and a personal brand.

The agent has handled difficult clients.

The agent has experienced complicated transactions.

The agent knows which situations are routine and which require additional brokerage involvement.

The agent still needs a brokerage. The agent still needs appropriate broker support.

But the nature of that need has changed.

We’ve explored this distinction in our discussion of how much brokerage support an experienced real estate agent actually needs.

The important point is simple: becoming more productive does not necessarily mean becoming more dependent on the brokerage.

But Traditional Brokerage Economics Can Work in the Opposite Direction

Consider an uncapped percentage-based commission split.

If the brokerage receives 20% of $100,000 in gross commission income subject to the split, that represents $20,000.

If the agent grows to $200,000, the same percentage represents $40,000.

At $300,000, it represents $60,000.

The agent became more successful.

The agent may also have become more independent.

Yet the amount paid to the brokerage increased substantially.

That’s the contradiction high-producing agents should examine.

The Brokerage Didn’t Necessarily Create the Growth

Ask yourself what actually caused your production to increase.

Was it a larger database?

More repeat business?

More referrals?

Better prospecting?

Personal advertising?

A stronger website?

Content you created?

See also  Florida Real Estate Agents Don't Need More Software. They Need Answers.

Relationships with investors?

A personal reputation built over hundreds of client interactions?

If those things drove your additional production, then the growth came from assets you built inside your business.

That matters when evaluating how much of the additional revenue should automatically flow to the brokerage.

Agents who generate their own real estate leads should pay particularly close attention to this calculation.

Your Brokerage Cost Should Not Be Invisible

One reason agents tolerate inefficient brokerage economics is that brokerage costs are not always experienced like normal business expenses.

If somebody sent you one invoice at the end of the year for $40,000, you would probably scrutinize it.

If the same $40,000 leaves incrementally as transactions close, it can attract far less attention.

The economic effect is the same.

That’s why producing agents should calculate the total amount paid to the brokerage every year.

Do not stop with the advertised commission split.

Calculate the applicable commission retained by the brokerage, transaction charges, recurring fees and other required brokerage costs under your particular arrangement.

Then look at the total.

Calculate the Cost of Every Closing

Once you know the annual number, calculate your effective brokerage cost per closing.

If you paid $30,000 across 30 transactions, the average brokerage cost was $1,000 per closing.

If you paid $45,000 across 30 transactions, the average was $1,500.

If you paid $60,000 across 30 transactions, it was $2,000.

Now you have a meaningful business metric.

You can compare that cost with the services you use and with alternative brokerage models.

Success Should Lower Your Relative Cost of Infrastructure

This concept is normal in business.

As a company grows, it looks for operating leverage.

Existing systems should support more revenue.

Processes should become more efficient.

Knowledge accumulated over time should reduce unnecessary work.

An established real estate business should benefit from the same principle.

Your database has already been built.

Your referral relationships already exist.

Your marketing systems are already operating.

Your experience already exists.

You created those assets so future production would become more efficient.

Your brokerage economics should not unnecessarily erase that advantage.

Your Next Closing Matters More Than Your First Closing

High-producing agents should think about marginal economics.

Ask:

What happens financially when I close one additional transaction?

Under an uncapped percentage split, brokerage compensation may continue increasing with each additional dollar of commission income.

Under a capped arrangement, the economics may change after the applicable cap is reached.

Under a transaction-based or 100% commission structure, the relationship between additional gross commission income and brokerage cost may be different again.

There is no substitute for running your specific numbers.

A Bigger Commission Shouldn’t Automatically Create a Bigger Brokerage Expense

Production can increase without transaction volume increasing dramatically.

See also  Your Real Estate Commission Split Isn't the Brokerage's Only Cut

Your average commission may simply increase.

Perhaps you move into a higher-priced geographic area.

Maybe your experience allows you to attract larger listings.

Your investor relationships may produce higher-value transactions.

Your personal brand may begin attracting a different type of client.

The resulting commission may be substantially larger.

We’ve examined this separately in why a bigger commission check shouldn’t automatically mean a bigger brokerage bill.

What’s important is understanding whether brokerage cost is increasing because the brokerage delivered more value or simply because the transaction generated more commission.

More Production Shouldn’t Automatically Mean More Brokerage Expense Either

The same applies to volume.

Perhaps your business grows from 20 closings to 30.

Those additional transactions represent success.

But before celebrating gross production alone, calculate what happens to your brokerage costs.

How much of the additional commission stays in your business?

How much goes to the brokerage?

What additional brokerage services were required?

That question is at the center of understanding brokerage fees for high-producing real estate agents.

Services You No Longer Need Still Have a Cost

A brokerage can provide excellent resources that have little value to a particular agent.

That isn’t a criticism of the resources.

It is a question of fit.

An established agent with a preferred CRM does not necessarily gain much from another included CRM.

An agent who generates all of their own business may place little value on a lead-generation system they rarely use.

An agent with established marketing may not need generic marketing resources.

A productive agent with effective systems may not need the same level of basic business instruction that was valuable earlier in a career.

Availability is not the same thing as value.

You should evaluate what your own business actually uses.

That Doesn’t Mean Support Should Disappear

A lower-cost brokerage relationship should not require an experienced agent to sacrifice legitimate brokerage support.

Producing agents still encounter unusual transactions, contract questions and compliance issues.

Access to competent brokerage support remains important.

The better question is whether the agent must pay for an expensive collection of unrelated services simply to receive the brokerage functions the agent actually needs.

This is why we’ve asked what a brokerage should provide to an independent real estate agent.

Experienced agents can want both independence and support.

Those ideas are not contradictory.

You Should Keep More of the Upside You Create

This is ultimately what favorable brokerage economics can accomplish.

If you increase production because your database is producing more referrals, more of that economic benefit can remain with your business.

If your marketing succeeds, there can be more money available to reinvest in the marketing.

See also  MLS Access for Non-REALTORS®

If your personal brand attracts better opportunities, you can retain more of the benefit created by that brand.

If you become more efficient, your bottom line can benefit from the efficiency.

That is how business leverage is supposed to work.

100% Commission Can Be Part of the Answer

For established producers, a 100% commission brokerage model can become particularly relevant because increased commission income does not necessarily result in the same traditional percentage-based brokerage deduction from every commission check.

But the phrase “100% commission” isn’t enough.

Producing agents must evaluate applicable transaction charges and any other required brokerage costs.

They should evaluate available broker support.

They should consider how the model fits their existing systems, personal brand and business.

That’s why 100% commission isn’t really the point. Control of the economics is.

The Best Brokerage for High-Producing Agents Should Scale in the Agent’s Favor

If you’re searching for the best brokerage for high-producing real estate agents, this may be the most important question to ask:

What happens to my brokerage cost as I become more successful?

Run the model at your current production.

Then increase production by 25%.

Increase it by 50%.

Model what happens if you double production.

Model what happens if your average commission increases.

Then compare the additional brokerage cost with the additional value you expect to receive.

A brokerage model that looks attractive at one production level may look completely different at another.

Recalculate the Relationship Every Year

Your production changes.

Your business changes.

Your lead sources change.

Your experience changes.

Your need for brokerage services changes.

So your brokerage relationship deserves a periodic financial review.

We’ve laid out that process in why high-producing agents should recalculate their brokerage every year.

Staying with the same brokerage can be a perfectly rational decision.

But it should remain a decision.

Success Should Improve the Deal

You should not become better at running your business only to discover that success made one of your biggest expenses grow even faster.

The years spent developing experience should matter.

The database should matter.

The referrals should matter.

The personal brand should matter.

The systems should matter.

The production should matter.

Together, those assets should create leverage for you.

So pull your numbers.

Calculate what the brokerage cost last year.

Calculate your cost per closing.

Look at where your clients came from.

Identify the brokerage resources you actually use.

Then calculate what happens if your business becomes considerably more successful next year.

Your brokerage doesn’t literally have to cost less every year. But as you become more successful and self-sufficient, the economics should increasingly work in your favor.

Get Exclusive Content & Insights

Join our community for the latest real estate industry trends, expert tips, and special offers delivered straight to your inbox.

Easy Realty Icon
Get Exclusive Content & Insights
Join our community for the latest real estate industry trends, expert tips, and special offers delivered straight to your inbox.
Easy Realty Icon

Request A Call

Fill out the form below, and we will be in touch shortly. 

Learn how we helped 100 top brands gain success