You Closed More Deals. Why Did Your Brokerage Make More Money Too?

Producing real estate agent reviewing brokerage costs after increasing annual transaction volume

Executive Summary

You closed more transactions, increased your income and became better at running your real estate business. So why did your brokerage automatically make more money too? For producing agents on percentage-based commission splits, growth can dramatically change the economics of the brokerage relationship. Here’s how to calculate what your brokerage is really costing you.

Liked this post? Share with others!

You Closed More Deals. Why Did Your Brokerage Make More Money Too?

You had a good year. You closed more transactions, increased your gross commission income and became more efficient at running your real estate business. But when you look at what you paid your brokerage, something feels backward: the more productive you became, the more money your brokerage made from your production.

For a producing real estate agent, that is worth examining.

A commission split can seem perfectly reasonable when an agent is getting started. But as production increases, the same percentage can turn into a very different dollar amount.

If you are doing more of the work, generating your own clients, managing your own marketing and operating an increasingly independent business, it may be time to ask a simple question:

Should your brokerage’s compensation automatically keep increasing just because yours does?

A Percentage Feels Different When Your Production Grows

Commission splits are easy to think about as percentages.

70/30.

80/20.

90/10.

But producing agents should stop looking at the percentage for a moment and translate the split into actual dollars.

Suppose an agent earns $100,000 in gross commission income and pays 20% to the brokerage. Before considering any other brokerage fees, that represents $20,000.

If that same agent grows production to $200,000 while remaining on the same split, the brokerage portion becomes $40,000.

At $300,000, it becomes $60,000.

The agent produced the additional business. The agent found or converted more clients. The agent handled more transactions. The agent’s business grew.

Yet under a percentage-based arrangement, the brokerage may automatically earn substantially more as well.

That does not necessarily make a commission split wrong. It does mean a producing agent should understand exactly what is being received in exchange for that growing cost.

Your Brokerage Cost Should Be Measured in Dollars, Not Just Percentages

Percentages can disguise the real size of an expense.

A 10% split sounds small.

But 10% of $50,000 is $5,000.

Ten percent of $200,000 is $20,000.

Ten percent of $400,000 is $40,000.

The percentage did not change. The economic impact did.

That is why experienced and high-producing agents should periodically calculate the total amount they are actually paying their brokerage.

Include the commission split, transaction fees and any recurring brokerage expenses that apply to your particular arrangement.

Then ask what those dollars are buying.

What Changed When You Became a Better Agent?

Early in an agent’s career, there may be a strong argument for paying more for the right environment.

A newer agent may need substantial education, guidance and help understanding brokerage procedures. The agent may also need assistance building systems and learning how to operate a real estate business.

But agents change.

A producing agent may eventually generate most or all of their own business.

See also  Foreclosures are Back - Agents Needed

The agent may have established personal marketing systems, a database, referral relationships, lead sources, transaction habits and a recognizable brand.

The agent may know how to manage clients and move transactions from contract to closing.

At that point, the brokerage relationship deserves another look.

If your need for day-to-day brokerage involvement has decreased while the amount you pay the brokerage has increased, you should understand why.

The Question Isn’t Whether a Brokerage Should Make Money

Of course a brokerage should make money.

A brokerage is a business.

There are real costs associated with operating one, maintaining systems, supporting agents, supervising transactions and meeting the brokerage’s obligations.

The more useful question for an agent is whether the brokerage’s compensation model still makes sense for the business that agent has built.

If you receive significant value from resources provided by your brokerage and believe the cost is worthwhile, the economics may work perfectly well.

But if you are paying tens of thousands of dollars primarily because your production increased, it is fair to examine that arrangement much more closely.

Production Can Change the Brokerage Equation

The best brokerage model for an agent doing a small number of transactions may not be the best brokerage model for the same agent several years later.

That is because brokerage economics can change dramatically as production rises.

Imagine two agents with the same 80/20 commission split.

One earns $50,000 in gross commission income. The 20% brokerage portion is $10,000.

Another earns $300,000. The same 20% represents $60,000.

Same split.

Very different business expense.

The producing agent should therefore ask whether the brokerage is delivering $60,000 worth of value to that agent’s business.

That is not an emotional question.

It is a business question.

More Production Doesn’t Always Require More Brokerage

There is another assumption worth challenging.

Does an agent who doubles production necessarily consume twice as much brokerage support?

Not necessarily.

In fact, many experienced agents become more self-sufficient as they become more productive.

They develop repeatable systems. They recognize problems earlier. They know which questions require broker involvement and which ones they can handle themselves. They become better at managing their own pipelines, clients and businesses.

That was one of the ideas we explored in our discussion of how much brokerage support an experienced real estate agent actually needs.

Producing more transactions certainly creates more activity. But activity and dependence are not the same thing.

An agent may simultaneously become more productive and more independent.

Agent-Generated Business Changes the Conversation Too

Where the business comes from matters.

If a brokerage provides a lead or client opportunity, an agent may reasonably evaluate the economics differently from a transaction generated entirely through the agent’s own prospecting, advertising, database, referrals or reputation.

See also  What “Broker Support” Should Mean (And Usually Doesn’t)

A producing agent who generates their own business has created something valuable.

The agent has developed a client acquisition engine.

That might consist of referrals, online marketing, geographic farming, content, paid advertising, investor relationships, open houses, a personal database or years of community involvement.

Whatever the source, building predictable business takes work and usually costs money.

If you are generating the opportunity and then giving a substantial percentage of the resulting commission to the brokerage, you should understand exactly what you receive in return.

We explored that issue separately in our guide to choosing a brokerage when you generate your own real estate leads.

Your Brand Has Value as Well

Producing agents frequently reach another turning point when clients begin seeking out the agent rather than merely responding to brokerage marketing.

Your name, reputation, database, content and relationships can become meaningful business assets.

You may be the reason the phone rings.

You may be the person a past client remembers.

You may have built the website, paid for the advertising, created the content or maintained the relationship that generated the next transaction.

At that point, agents should pay close attention to whether their brokerage arrangement supports the business they built or simply takes a larger share as that business becomes more successful.

For agents building around their own identity, we have also looked at what to consider when choosing a brokerage while building your own real estate brand.

Calculate Your Effective Brokerage Cost

Here is a useful exercise for producing agents.

Take the total amount you paid your brokerage during the last full year.

Do not look only at your advertised commission split.

Look at the entire relationship.

Depending on your brokerage agreement, that could include amounts retained through commission splits, transaction fees, recurring brokerage charges or other required fees.

Then calculate what that cost represented for your business.

For example, if your total brokerage cost was $30,000 and you closed 30 sides during the year, your average brokerage cost was $1,000 per closing.

If you paid $45,000 across 30 closings, your average was $1,500.

Now you have a number you can evaluate.

You can compare that cost with the services and support you actually used.

You can also compare it with alternative brokerage models available to an established producing agent.

Don’t Compare Brokerage Models Using One Number

A commission split is only one part of brokerage economics.

A brokerage advertising a 100% commission model can still have fees.

A brokerage with a split may have a cap.

Another brokerage may include services that an agent would otherwise purchase separately.

See also  Build Your Real Estate Niche: Specialty Training and Education for Easy Realty Agents

Different models can therefore produce very different results depending on the individual agent’s production and needs.

The useful comparison is not:

“Which brokerage has the biggest commission percentage?”

It is:

“What will this brokerage actually cost my business, and what am I receiving for that money?”

That is a much harder question for marketing slogans to answer.

It is also a much better question for a producing agent to ask.

Your Brokerage Model Should Still Make Sense at Your Next Production Level

Do not evaluate a brokerage solely around the business you did last year.

Think about where you are going.

If you increase production by 25%, what happens to your brokerage cost?

What happens if you double production?

Does the amount retained by the brokerage rise proportionally with your success?

Is there a cap?

Are your transaction costs predictable?

Will you receive additional value as your brokerage expense increases?

A brokerage model that seems inexpensive at one production level can become much more expensive at another.

Producing agents should understand that before the additional transactions close, not after they see the year-end total.

The Best Brokerage for a Producing Agent May Look Different

When agents search for the best brokerage for high-producing real estate agents, the answer should not be based on production awards, recruiting slogans or the size of the brokerage.

The economics have to work for the individual agent.

A productive, self-sufficient agent may place greater value on keeping more commission, maintaining control of their business, having appropriate broker support available when it is actually needed and avoiding unnecessary layers of cost.

Another agent may intentionally choose a more expensive structure because that agent uses and values services included with it.

Both can be rational decisions.

What does not make sense is paying substantially more simply because nobody stopped to recalculate the relationship after the agent became more productive.

Success Should Improve the Economics of Your Business

Your brokerage relationship is a business relationship.

That means it deserves the same scrutiny you would give any other major business expense.

If your production increased last year, pull the numbers.

Calculate what you actually paid your brokerage.

Calculate the average brokerage cost per closing.

Look at which brokerage resources you actually used.

Then model what the same arrangement will cost if you have an even better year.

You might discover that your current model still makes complete sense.

Or you might discover something else:

You closed more deals, became a more valuable and self-sufficient agent, and somehow made your brokerage substantially more money in the process.

If that’s the case, asking why is not being disloyal.

It’s running your business.

Get Exclusive Content & Insights

Join our community for the latest real estate industry trends, expert tips, and special offers delivered straight to your inbox.

Easy Realty Icon
Get Exclusive Content & Insights
Join our community for the latest real estate industry trends, expert tips, and special offers delivered straight to your inbox.
Easy Realty Icon

Request A Call

Fill out the form below, and we will be in touch shortly. 

Learn how we helped 100 top brands gain success